North Point vs The Gathering: Two Arenas, No Team

In the early hours of August 25, after a meeting that ran past midnight, Alpharetta City Council voted 4–3 to rezone 98.58 acres at North Point Mall for a district anchored by an NHL-ready arena of 17,500 to 20,000 seats. The city dates the approval August 24; news accounts date the vote August 25. Same meeting.

The coverage mostly stopped there. Three things it left out are the ones that actually matter if you own property near either GA 400 exit.

Quick answer

There are two competing arena sites on GA 400 — North Point in Alpharetta and The Gathering in South Forsyth — bidding for one hypothetical team. Forsyth has been entitled and voter-funded since 2025. And the NHL's next expansion is aimed at Texas — Houston or Austin — though the league has made no decision, with Atlanta discussed only as a possible team after that.

Aerial illustrative rendering of the proposed North Point district, showing the arena beside GA 400 with mid-rise residential, office and structured parking around it. — What was approved, as the applicant drew it: the arena fronting GA 400, wrapped by mid-rise residential, office and structured parking. An illustrative rendering filed with the case — not a construction document, and contingent on a franchise that does not exist. Source: applicant presentation, City of Alpharetta case MP-26-06/Z-26-05/CU-26-04/V-26-08 (New York Life / Jamestown LP / Machete / HKS / Kimley-Horn).

Since this was published — updated October 2026

A third Atlanta bid split off. Anson Carter separated from the Alpharetta group and is pursuing his own bid with no site chosen, looking north of Atlanta (Bill Daly to ESPN, September 9).
The Gathering started grading its South Forsyth site around September 7 — roughly five months of work across 90-plus acres. Daly rebuked the group for premature claims.
Texas is not settled. Daly, September 10: “I don't want to treat it like a done deal, because it's not.”
No decision at the September 22 Board of Governors meeting. Expansion was discussed; no vote, no timetable. The next Board meeting is in December.

Map of the GA 400 corridor showing North Point in Alpharetta and The Gathering in South Forsyth, roughly ten miles apart. — The two sites sit about ten miles apart on the same highway — North Point at GA 400 Exit 9 in Alpharetta, The Gathering near the Union Hill / Ronald Reagan exits in South Forsyth. Map data © OpenStreetMap contributors.

2Rival sites

0Teams awarded

2031Alpharetta deadline

Correction one: Forsyth never lost

A lot of people filed The Gathering away as a dead project. It isn't.

In November 2024, Forsyth County voters approved a tax allocation district for the project by roughly 56–44, covering about 100.3 acres of county land and funding the county's $225 million share. Final agreements followed in June 2025. It has been entitled and funded for over a year — longer than Alpharetta's project has existed on paper.

So this isn't a story about one city winning. It's two fully entitled districts on the same highway, waiting on the same thing.

Correction two: there is no team

Both districts are contingent on an NHL franchise that has not been awarded to anyone.

The league's actual expansion is pointed at Texas. Deputy commissioner Bill Daly has said a 33rd franchise could be awarded as soon as the end of 2026, with Houston and Austin the two cities in play. Bettman announced on June 23, 2026 that the league was beginning a roughly six-month exploration with the Friedkin family, a project NHL.com put at about $3.5 billion in total including the arena. Play is projected to start in 2029–30. No franchise has been awarded.

The league has said it is talking to at least two groups about a 34th team, and Atlanta has been raised as a possible market. But none of those conversations are as far along as the Texas one.

The engineer's read

Strip out the hockey and this is a straightforward entitlement question. Both cities have now approved a very large mixed-use district and attached the housing, hotel and office components to a condition neither city controls.

Alpharetta's approval is explicit about it. Condition 1, as adopted on August 24, reads in part:

“If the property owner provides satisfactory written evidence to the City that the National Hockey League (NHL) awarded a franchise team to the North Point site on or before August 24, 2031, the property shall be developed substantially similar to the site plan … ; or … if no written notice is provided to the City as required by 1(a) above, the property may be developed in accordance with the current entitlements for the property as of August 23, 2026.”

So it is the whole plan, not just the apartments, that rides on the franchise — and if no team is awarded by August 2031, the property falls back to the entitlements it already had. That is a five-year option, not a construction schedule. Seventy-four conditions sit behind it — a proposed seventy-fifth, which would have required a public referendum on TAD bonds, was rejected.

Forsyth's advantage is deliverability — it is funded and entitled and does not need the league's permission to start moving dirt. Alpharetta's advantage is desirability: a marquee developer in Jamestown, the Avalon track record next door, a planned transit station, and a hundred thousand daytime commuters already in the area.

The honest read is that neither breaks ground on an arena soon, and possibly neither ever does. The gate is a league decision that is years out and currently aimed somewhere else.

Head to head

North PointAlpharetta (Fulton) · 98.58 ac · arena 17,500–20,000 seats · rezoned 4–3 at the Aug 24–25, 2026 meeting · 74 conditions · reverts if no NHL by Aug 2031
BackersJamestown (Ponce City Market) with New York Life and The Machete Group
The GatheringSouth Forsyth · ~100.3 ac county land · TAD approved by voters ~56–44 in Nov 2024 · final agreements June 2025 · county share $225M
Shared dependencyAn NHL franchise that has not been awarded to either
League posture33rd team to Houston or Austin, possibly by end of 2026; play projected 2029–30

What's actually in the filing

The city posts the full case package, and it is more specific than the coverage suggested. The illustrative site plan filed with the application shows a multi-purpose arena, a live music venue, a team practice facility with community ice, a cinema, two hotels, retail with residential above, structured parking — and a vertiport. The existing Dillard's is retained.

Illustrative site plan for the North Point Mixed-Use District showing a multi-purpose arena, live music venue, team practice facility with community ice, vertiport, cinema, hotels, retail with residential above, and structured parking. — The illustrative site plan filed with case MP-26-06/Z-26-05/CU-26-04/V-26-08. The arena is upper right; the team practice facility and community ice sit at the west end; Dillard's is retained at the bottom. Credited to New York Life, Jamestown LP, Machete, HKS and Kimley-Horn, dated 03.16.26. Source: City of Alpharetta public hearing case documents.

Illustrative rendering of the North Point ICEPLEX and public plaza, with the arena visible beyond and existing mall structures retained at right. — The community-ice building — labelled ICEPLEX in the applicant's rendering — with the arena beyond and existing mall anchors retained at right. This is the piece that would get used year-round whether or not a franchise ever arrives. Source: applicant presentation, City of Alpharetta.

One detail from the applicant's own parking analysis is worth pulling out, because it says the quiet part plainly:

"While additional parking will be needed for hockey games, arena event parking is unnecessary for approximately 85% of the year. During the regular NHL season, there are 41 home games, compared with 81 home games in Major League Baseball."

The district is explicitly not being built to park a sold-out arena on site. The filing says peak-event demand is to be handled with a mix of on- and off-site parking, deliberately, to avoid overbuilding a deck that sits empty most of the year. That is sound engineering. It also means that on the biggest nights, the overflow goes somewhere — and if you own nearby, that somewhere is worth thinking about now rather than in 2031.

Method summary card: two rival sites, zero teams awarded, 2031 Alpharetta deadline. — The situation in three numbers.

Why it matters

If you own near North Point: an approved entitlement is not a construction date. The near-term, non-contingent piece is retail redevelopment of the mall property — the arena, apartments, hotel and office all sit behind the franchise condition. Price the retail change as real and the arena as an option.

If you own in South Forsyth: your project has been funded and entitled since 2025 and does not need the NHL's permission to build the non-arena components. Watch for actual construction activity, which is a far better signal than either city's press cycle.

If you're buying anywhere along the corridor: be careful about paying an arena premium today. You would be paying for a franchise that does not exist, at a site that is one of two candidates, in a league whose next team is aimed at Texas and not yet decided. If it happens, it is a 2030s story.

What we don't know yet

Whether the NHL awards a 34th team at all, or where
Which site the league would prefer if Atlanta is ever selected
Whether either developer proceeds with non-arena phases in the meantime
Whether Alpharetta's 2031 deadline gets extended if the league timeline slips

I'll update this as the league's expansion decision develops.

FAQ

Is Atlanta getting an NHL team?

Not currently. The NHL's next franchise is expected to go to Houston or Austin, potentially announced by the end of 2026. Atlanta has been mentioned as a candidate for a subsequent team, but no decision has been made.

What was approved at North Point Mall?

A rezoning of 98.58 acres for a mixed-use district anchored by a proposed arena of 17,500 to 20,000 seats, passed 4–3 in the August 24–25, 2026 council meeting with 74 conditions. The no votes were Council Members Brady, DeRito and Reeves. The housing, hotel and office components are contingent on landing an NHL franchise by August 2031.

Is The Gathering in Forsyth dead?

No. Forsyth County voters approved its tax allocation district roughly 56–44 in November 2024, and final agreements were reached in June 2025. It is entitled and funded.

Should I buy near one of these sites because of the arena?

That's a speculative bet on a franchise that hasn't been awarded, at one of two competing sites, on a timeline that runs to the 2030s at the earliest. Buy the house and the location on their own merits.

Source note: The North Point approval — the 4–3 vote, the 98.58-acre scope, the 17,500–20,000-seat arena, the Jamestown / New York Life / Machete Group team, the 74 conditions and the August 2031 franchise contingency — is as reported by the AJC, Atlanta News First, Rough Draft Atlanta and Axios Atlanta. NHL expansion status, the Houston/Austin shortlist, the 2029–30 projected start and the 34th-team discussions are as reported by TSN, the Houston Chronicle and NHL.com, citing deputy commissioner Bill Daly. Bettman's June 23, 2026 announcement of the Texas exploration and the roughly $3.5 billion total figure including the arena are from NHL.com. An earlier version of this article said Dan Friedkin had already agreed to a $2 billion expansion fee; I could not verify that figure and have removed it. The Gathering's November 2024 TAD referendum (~56–44), the ~100.3 acres, the $225 million county share and the June 2025 final agreements are as reported by Atlanta News First, Urbanize Atlanta and Forsyth County. The illustrative site plan, the vertiport, the team practice facility and community ice, the retained Dillard's, the design credits and the parking analysis quotation are read directly from the case package the City of Alpharetta publishes for MP-26-06/Z-26-05/CU-26-04/V-26-08 on its Public Hearings page, where the case is listed as Approved with Conditions 8.24. Comparative analysis is from my own MarketIQ comparative site brief. No NHL franchise has been awarded to either site, and this report makes no prediction that one will be.

Want what I'm tracking?

I read the zoning agendas for Alpharetta, Roswell, Milton, Woodstock, Acworth and Cumming every week — usually months before anything gets reported. Comment INTEL and I'll send you what's moving near you.

Matt Fasano · Method Real Estate Advisors

Two GA 400 Arenas, and No NHL Team to Put in Them